Skip to content
OddLingo
Back to Proverbs
proverbs4 min read

You Can't Get Blood from a Stone

You can't get blood from a stone means that you cannot get something from a person who simply does not have it.

⚡ Quick Meaning

Some things are simply not there. That is the point of you can't get blood from a stone: it is no use asking a person for something they do not have, whether it is money, time or a skill.

🪨 Wait... Is It Just Hard?

A STONE HAS NO BLOOD, SO THERE IS NOTHING TO GET.

Is this only a saying about something very hard to do? ❌
Or is it a picture of something that is not there at all? ✅

That is the OddLingo twist. Squeezing a heavy stone is hard work, but the picture is about the stone: it has no blood, so no amount of squeezing will help. You will also hear like getting blood from a stone for something very hard to get out of a person, such as an answer from someone who does not want to give it. The picture behind both is the same: the squeezing does not help.

Look at the grammar. Get here means obtain, and from names the place you are trying to get it. You may also hear out of instead: you can't get blood out of a stone.

🎬 Picture the Situation

The robot club needs money for a new battery. Maya turns to the newest member, Sam, and asks for five pounds.

"I would love to help," says Sam, turning out his empty pockets. "I spent my last coin on the bus."

Maya laughs and puts her notebook away. "I should have known," she says. "You can't get blood from a stone."

Sam grins. "I can bring biscuits on Friday."

🗣️ Natural Examples

Asking the youngest cousin for a loan is silly. You can't get blood from a stone.
The team has no spare players, so we cannot ask for more. You can't get blood from a stone.
I have no free time this week, so please stop asking. You can't get blood from a stone.
She has not learnt any Spanish yet, so she cannot translate. You can't get blood from a stone.

💬 In a Conversation

Zoe: Can you lend me twenty pounds?
Omar: I have two pounds.
Zoe: Only two?
Omar: You can't get blood from a stone.

🔄 The Proverb That Argues Back

English also says where there's a will, there's a way, which says that if you really want something, you can find a route.

  • Where there's a will, there's a way: the thing is possible, so keep trying.
  • You can't get blood from a stone: the thing is not there, so stop asking.

A quick test: is there anything to get? If the thing is there and only needs effort, use the proverb about the way. If there is nothing to get, use the stone.

A neighbour is Easier Said Than Done, which is about a task that is hard to carry out, not one that cannot be done.

🧭 When Do You Use It?

  • When someone is asking for something that the other person does not have
  • To explain kindly why asking again will not work
  • With a smile, about money, time or a skill
  • As a simile, like getting blood from a stone, for something very hard to get out of a person
  • Not about a job that is only difficult. Where effort can work, the proverb about the way fits better.
  • Not as a way to tease someone who really has nothing to give.

⚠️ Common Mistakes

The core use is for something that is not there.
❌ There are plenty of chairs in the next room, but I cannot be bothered. You can't get blood from a stone.
✅ There are no spare chairs anywhere in the school. You can't get blood from a stone.

The word is stone.
❌ You can't get blood from a stones.
✅ You can't get blood from a stone.

Use from or out of.
❌ You can't get blood at a stone.
✅ You can't get blood from a stone. (Or: out of a stone.)

💡 The OddLingo Trick

Picture someone squeezing a grey stone with both hands. Their face goes red. The stone stays dry.

Then ask one question: is the thing really there? If it is, keep trying. If it is not, the stone has the answer.

Related: see Where There's a Will, There's a Way for the opposite attitude, and Easier Said Than Done for a task that is hard but possible.

📜 Where Did It Come From?

The Phrase Finder says the proverb probably began in Italian, and that Giovanni Torriano's collections of Italian proverbs from 1662 have close versions, including one that uses a turnip instead of a stone. It names Vicesimus Knox's Winter Evenings (1788) as the first record in English. The turnip form, you can't get blood out of a turnip, is the one best known in the United States.

🎯 Test Your Skill

Four questions. Nothing is squeezed.

Back to Proverbs

Spotted a mistake or have a better example? Tell OddLingo or write to [email protected].